Welcome to Brother's Pizza Flushing
Brother's Pizza Flushing embodies the spirit of the quintessential New York pizzeria. Established decades ago, this beloved neighborhood spot on Horace Harding Expressway serves classic, old-school pizza, drawing in regulars who savor its crunchy crust, melty cheese, and flavorful sauce. With options like the Grandma Pie and Sicilian Cheese Pie, each bite delivers nostalgic flavors reminiscent of simpler times. Patrons rave about the friendly service and inviting atmosphere, where conversations about baseball and life flourish. Whether you enjoy a quick slice at the counter or dine in for the freshest pie, Brother's Pizza remains a cherished gem in Flushing, offering a taste of authentic Italian American heritage.
-
185-04 Horace Harding Expy, Flushing, NY 11365 Hotline: (718) 445-7888
Welcome to the heart of Flushing, New York, where tradition meets flavor at Brother's Pizza Flushing. Located at 185-04 Horace Harding Expy, this charming pizzeria has been serving up authentic, old-school New York-style pizza for decades. With a phone call away at (718) 445-7888, it’s a haven for pizza lovers and a comforting reminder of the comforting, classic dishes that have remained unchanged through the years.
At Brother's, every pie tells a story. As you enter this beloved neighborhood establishment, you're greeted by the warm, nostalgic ambiance of yesteryears—think wood paneling and spinning bar stools, all witnesses to countless conversations about baseball and football. It's a place where regulars gather, sharing laughter and memories over slices that evoke fond childhood recollections of pizza days past.
- Menu Highlights: The offerings range from classic pizzas—like the Grandma Pizza and Sicilian Pizza—to delightful appetizers such as Buffalo Wings and Chicken Tenders. Each dish is prepared with genuine care and attention.
- Fan Favorites: The real stars here are the cheesy goodness and crunchy crust. Customers rave about the exceptionally flavorful and herbaceous cheese that sets Brother's apart from other pizzerias.
- Affordability: With a slice starting at just $3.75, indulging in that satisfying flavor doesn't have to break the bank. The prices remain reasonable, turning pizza nights into weekly traditions for many.
In the words of satisfied customers, the pizza at Brother's is “simply the best”, a sentiment echoed by generations. As the reviews suggest, the classic New York style Neapolitan pizzas—whether round or Sicilian—are best enjoyed fresh out of the oven, but they also hold up well for takeout. Just don’t forget to pair your meal with a classic 2-liter soda for that nostalgic touch!
So next time you’re in search of a meal that feels like home, make your way to Brother's Pizza Flushing. It’s not merely about the food—it's about feeling connected to a community that celebrates every slice, every laugh, and every shared moment. At Brother's, you’re not just a customer; you’re part of the family.
Old school pizza was, is and will ALWAYS be the best. 62 years and still going strong.
Good pizza. Old school pizza like I remember when I was a kid. Crunchy crust. Melty cheese and tasty sauce. Always consitant.
Best pizza in America lowkey. That cheese? Omg it just hits different. It's so flavorful and herbaceous and different from every other pizza place. The service is good too but the pizza is just phenomenal.
Excellent amount of cheese and a bit of a thinner crust than a normal place. A good ratio of crust to cheese for me. Staff were very kind and friendly. The interior is dated but good pizza comes from places that don't need updating. Would order my next pie from here.
Brother's is old school neighborhood pizzeria that has been at this location on Horace Harding Expy for decades. The pizza oven is older than me, the wood paneling has seen better days and the spinning counter stools have seen a lot of bottoms. The most recent renovation is the new exterior sign because the old one was missing a lot of letters. During Covid, they had put up a curbside shack to expand seating, but eventually, it had to be removed. When you walk in, there are always a bunch of regulars at the counter stools having lunch and talking baseball in the Spring and football in the Fall. The Mets rule here. I still remember the first time I had a slice from Brother's was at a birthday party that my son was invited to over 20 years ago. After seeing the name on the box and tasting the pizza, I made a mental bookmark (B.Y., Before Yelp) to check them out. And the rest is history, though I waited until now to write a review. The pizza is classic New York style Neapolitan, round thin crust and Sicilian thick squares. It's best to order and dine-in for the freshest, hottest tasting pie, but if you must take-out, it's still not bad when you get it home. I hate using one of the delivery services because you don't know how long it takes to get your pizza. We love it with sausage and usually mushrooms, but the mushrooms are not fresh here, coming out of a jar. The heroes here are really good made fresh in the kitchen. The Veal Parmagiana hero is great and I'll have to try some of the others for lunch. Prices are very reasonable, even after post-Covid inflation. Definitely have to try the pasta dinners next time because they make a good sweet red sauce.
Getting into LGA late at night I looked for some pizza places on the way home and this seemed good. It was okay. I think we just do it better on long island, though queens is technically long island, not about to start all that :P nassau county whatever. It was perfect for us as we headed home right off the parkway.